Paths to Capitol Hill
The Fifteenth Amendment ushered in an extraordinary decade in Congress. Sixteen Black lawmakers, nearly three-quarters of the 22 Black Members who served in Congress during the nineteenth century, served in the 10 years after its ratification. The rapid pace of change was consistent with the bold optimism among African-American activists at the beginning of the decade. In December 1870, the month Joseph Rainey was sworn in as the first Black U.S. Representative in American history, Frederick Douglass’s newspaper, the New National Era, cited one enthusiastic prediction that neatly connected the Black share of the U.S. population with the seats in the House, expecting that proportional representation would quickly lead to the election of 34 African Americans in Congress. Black voters, now fully counted in the southern states to determine apportionment, would be afforded “strength and power” in the next election, with “a status that neither party can afford to despise.”19
In a way, the 38-year-old Rainey represented a composite of Black Members elected to the Congress during the nineteenth century. Born enslaved, Rainey was emancipated through the efforts of his father, who purchased his freedom. Rainey had little in the way of a formal education. He was trained in his father’s profession and worked as a barber in Charleston, South Carolina, before the Civil War. He escaped to Bermuda during the war, continued working as a barber, and returned to South Carolina following the conflict. He was a dedicated member of the state Republican Party, organizing at the local level, participating in the 1868 state constitutional convention, and serving in the state senate from 1868 to 1870.
With the exception of his years in Bermuda, Rainey’s early life, education, work, and political activism were largely comparable to those of his Black colleagues in the 1870s. Many were born enslaved or had parents who were enslaved. The vast majority were self-taught and demonstrated knowledge of contemporary literature, the classics, and the law in their remarks before Congress. They embraced the pursuit of public service and political power as state and local office holders before coming to Congress. And all were activists enmeshed in the ongoing struggle for civil and political rights in the South.
A Generation Forged in Upheaval
The vast majority of Black Members elected during the nineteenth century grew up in the antebellum South, a region marked by revolutionary changes in politics and society in the 1860s. Eleven were born enslaved and two more were born to parents who had been emancipated—only Robert Brown Elliott of South Carolina and James E. O’Hara of North Carolina were born and raised elsewhere. Some like Rainey gained freedom well before the Civil War, others like Jeremiah Haralson of Alabama were enslaved until 1865. Robert Smalls of South Carolina became a sensation in 1862, when he commandeered a Confederate ship and led a daring escape from Charleston harbor that freed his and other enslaved families. Smalls’s exploits immediately became national news, and he later piloted several ships for the U.S. Navy in the war.21
Black Members who served during the 1870s had diverse educational backgrounds. Few had any formal education, as southern states banned teaching both free and enslaved Black children to read and write. Free Black communities, along with sympathetic White neighbors, sometimes operated schools to teach those enslaved in southern cities. Others, like Frederick Douglass, who, as a young man was enslaved in Baltimore, Maryland, learned to read and write using a variety of creative tactics and sheer determination. After the Civil War, schools were funded by state and local governments as well as the Freedmen’s Bureau. By 1870, more than 4,000 schools in the South served nearly a quarter-million students.22
The six Black lawmakers elected for the first time after 1880 had more formal schooling than their predecessors. All had attended college or earned degrees. Several were lawyers, including John M. Langston of Virginia, who went to Oberlin College in Ohio before the war and had a distinguished legal career.
Black Representatives and Senators in the nineteenth century worked in trades and developed important skills before coming to Congress. They were ambitious barbers, tailors, printers, hotel managers, steamboat porters, photographers, and store owners. Most were educators: Seven worked as teachers and five as school administrators. Others were clergymen and farmers.24
In some cases, shrewd business investments enabled nineteenth-century Black Congressmen to become affluent. They were planters and landowners. They backed railroad ventures and engaged in real estate speculation. At least seven Members held estates of more than $5,000, a considerable sum at the time. Senator Blanche K. Bruce of Mississippi, the wealthiest among them, amassed a fortune of more than $150,000 primarily through real estate and farming.25
Almost every Black Member of Congress in the nineteenth century held widespread influence in state and local politics before arriving on Capitol Hill. Of the 22 Black Members of Congress elected before 1901, only Jefferson F. Long of Georgia and Charles E. Nash of Louisiana did not hold public office before serving in Congress. Four served in local office, two held federal appointments, and 14 sat in their state’s legislature before their election to Congress. In fact, John Langston was one of the first Black officeholders in U.S. history, having been elected clerk of Brownhelm, Ohio, in 1855; he later served as a U.S. diplomat in Haiti and Santo Domingo.
Opportunities and Obstacles
Black Members during the nineteenth century represented states and congressional districts undergoing dramatic change during Reconstruction. Southern states elected new leaders, redrew district boundaries, and empowered new constituencies of Black voters across the region.
Majority-Black districts proved crucial for electing African-American Representatives. Only two Black Members during this era served a district whose population was less than 50-percent Black. Republicans in control of state legislatures at the beginning of the 1870s drew favorable congressional districts to boost the party’s candidates at the polls. As speaker of the Mississippi state assembly in 1872, John Lynch was directly involved in the reapportionment of the state’s six seats in the U.S. House, creating five Republican-dominated districts before winning election in the Sixth District later that year.26
South Carolina elected eight Black Members during this period—the most of any state—from multiple districts with majority-Black populations. In North Carolina, gerrymandering created the state’s lone majority-Black district. Black candidates frequently competed against each other in the so-called “Black Second,” and the district was represented by four Black Representatives before 1901. But with the exception of Alabama and Mississippi, both of which elected three Black Members, Black candidates found less success in the other southern states. Florida, Georgia, Louisiana, and Virginia each elected one Black Representative. Of the states that were once part of the Confederate rebellion, Arkansas, Texas, and Tennessee sent no Black Members to Congress during this period.27
Even in districts with large Black populations, Black congressional candidates faced significant challenges. Violence, murder, and intimidation were commonplace during congressional campaigns in many parts of the postwar South. Congressional committees compiled voluminous firsthand accounts describing threats, beatings, and murders perpetrated against African Americans and their White allies in the Republican Party.28
In 1872, Samuel Peters of Shreveport and P.B.S. Pinchback of New Orleans both won election to the House from Louisiana, but neither was ever seated. Peters was a Black teacher and activist from Ohio who in 1871 moved to Louisiana, where he took charge of the Shreveport branch of the Freedman’s Savings and Trust Company, also known as the Freedman’s Bank. He was also appointed division superintendent of education by Pinchback, then the state’s acting governor and one of the first Black state executives in U.S. history. Peters was elected to the House in November 1872, but the 43rd Congress (1873−1875) was not scheduled to convene until December 1873. In September, yellow fever decimated Shreveport, leaving more than 400 dead, including Peters. He died just months before he would have taken the oath of office.30
Pinchback faced a different fate. Born in Georgia, he had been a gambler on Mississippi riverboats before his arrival in New Orleans in the early 1860s. After service in the U.S. Army during the Civil War, he was elected to the Louisiana state senate. He served as lieutenant governor of the state and spent 35 days as acting governor. In 1872, he was elected to an At-Large U.S. House seat from Louisiana. He was subsequently chosen as the next U.S. Senator from Louisiana on January 17, 1873. His claim to seats in both houses of Congress was challenged by his opponents, who disputed his credentials for each position. While the state endured months of violent confrontations between Democrats and Republicans, two competing candidates laid claim to the governor’s office. Pinchback spoke on the House Floor on June 8, 1874, defending the legitimacy of his election to the House. When the House Committee on Elections ruled in favor of his opponent, Pinchback pursued his claim in the Senate to no avail.31
Menard and Pinchback were ensnared in the convoluted contested election process, which was exceedingly common during the nineteenth century. In the House, the Committee on Elections handled contested cases. Established as the House’s first standing committee in 1789, it rendered judgments on disputed elections based on evidence and witness testimony. The panel’s deliberations often extended well into the second session, and the majority party’s candidate had a distinct advantage because votes on each case were often decided along party lines within the committee and on the House Floor. Members forced to defend their seats during contested election investigations lost valuable time in introducing legislation or speaking on the House Floor. The committee handled an unusually heavy caseload in the half century following the Civil War: 60 percent of cases heard by the committee between 1867 and 1911 were from the former Confederacy—a disproportionate share given that Representatives from those eleven states constituted close to 25 percent of the House.32
Black Representatives in the nineteenth century routinely had their elections challenged, often to devastating effect. The first sitting Black Member to face a contested election was Robert C. De Large of South Carolina, who had joined the 42nd Congress in March of 1871. After accusations of election fraud from an Independent Republican opponent, the committee recommended his seat declared vacant. The whole House voted to remove De Large from office on January 24, 1873, sending him home five weeks early.33
White Democrats used this forum to challenge the victories of Black Republicans. Josiah T. Walls of Florida was elected three consecutive times to the House between 1870 and 1874 but was unseated twice by Democratic challengers following decisions by the Committee on Elections. In the 44th and 45th Congresses (1875–1879), the Democratic Party controlled the House for the first time since the Civil War. Three Black Members in each Congress endured protracted battles before the Committee on Elections but successfully held on to their seats.34
About this record Joseph Rainey’s election credentials from 1874 mark the South Carolinian’s fourth victory for a House seat.
Several Black candidates unsuccessfully challenged the elections of White Democrats who claimed victory at the polls. They found the committee more receptive to their efforts when Republicans controlled the House, however. During the 1880s and 1890s, five Black contestants unseated White Members who had declared victory on Election Day.36
The Election Committee’s mercurial decision-making and lengthy proceedings provoked many Members to question its motives and efficacy. The politicized nature of its decisions—and the role of local officials, largely White Democrats, in the vote-counting process as well as the imprecise manner in which vote counts were examined, deciphered, and ruled upon—placed Black candidates at a distinct disadvantage. In a letter to the committee in January 1880, Jeremiah Haralson scolded the committee for the way it handled his 1878 election defeat. Haralson had contested his Democratic opponent’s victory that year, citing fraud and intimidation at the polls in a district where an overwhelming majority of registered voters were Black and Republican. He had been unable to collect testimony from individuals in his district after potential witnesses had been jailed. And he was threatened, indicted, and forced to leave the state. After months of silence, the committee notified him in early 1880 that the contest was going to be dismissed if he did not submit additional documentation regarding his claims. For Haralson, the Democratic House majority had engaged in ruthless bureaucratic maneuvering that revealed a lack of integrity among its members. “The devil will be compelled to look out when the committee on elections of the Forty-sixth Congress gets there, (I mean hell),” Haralson warned, “or they will declare he is not entitled to the seat he holds, or not report at all.”37
Footnotes
19“The Negro Power,” 8 December 1870, New National Era (Washington, DC): 4.
20“The Radicals at Marion,” 22 August 1870, Charleston Daily News: 4; “Two Colored Candidates for Congress in South Carolina,” 17 August 1870, Boston Herald: 4; Michael J. Dubin, United States Congressional Elections, 1788–1997 (Jefferson, NC: McFarland & Co., Inc., Publishers, 1998): 214, 220.
21Senate Committee on Privileges and Elections, Report of the Senate Committee on Privileges and Elections, 44th Cong., 2nd sess., S. Rept. 704 (1877): 191; “Gallant Act of A Negro Pilot,” 21 May 1862, Chicago Tribune: 1; “Promotion of Robert Small,” 17 December 1863, Chicago Tribune: 2.
22Eugene D. Genovese, Roll, Jordan, Roll: The World the Slaves Made (New York: Pantheon Books, 1974): 561–564; Richard C. Wade, Slavery in the Cities: The South, 1820–1860 (London: Oxford University Press, 1964): 173–176; Ira Berlin, Slaves Without Masters: The Free Negro in the Antebellum South (New York: The New Press, 1974): 304–305; Blight, Frederick Douglass: 35–47; John Hope Franklin and Alfred A. Moss, From Slavery to Freedom: A History of African Americans, 8th ed. (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 2000): 257.
23John Roy Lynch, Reminiscences of an Active Life: The Autobiography of John Roy Lynch, ed. John Hope Franklin (Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1970): 42–43.
24Douglas W. Bristol, Knights of the Razor: Black Barbers in Slavery and Freedom (Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2009): 126–127.
25Foner, Freedom’s Lawmakers: xxii; Lawrence Otis Graham, The Senator and the Socialite: The True Story of America’s First Black Dynasty (New York: HarperCollins, 2006): 5–7.
26Josiah T. Walls in the 42nd Congress (1871–1873) and James T. Rapier of Alabama in the 43rd Congress (1873–1875). Senators Hiram R. Revels and Blanche K. Bruce were both elected to the Senate by Republican-controlled state legislatures in Mississippi, a state whose population was more than 50 percent Black in 1870. Stanley B. Parsons et al., United States Congressional Districts, 1843–1883 (New York: Greenwood Press, 1986): 99, 146; Foner, Freedom’s Lawmakers: xiii; John R. Lynch, The Facts of Reconstruction (1913; repr., New York: Arno Press, 1969): 66–69.
27George W. Reid, “Four in Black: North Carolina’s Black Congressmen, 1874–1901,” Journal of Negro History 64, no. 3 (Summer 1979): 229–243; Eric Anderson, Race and Politics in North Carolina, 1872–1901: The Black Second (Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press, 1981).
28Foner, Reconstruction: 442–443; Joint Select Committee on the Condition of Affairs in the Late Insurrectionary States, Affairs in the Late Insurrectionary States, 42nd Cong., 2nd sess., H. Rept. 22, part 1 (1872). The Joint Committee investigation produced 13 volumes from extensive testimony from hearings held in Washington and throughout the South.
29Dubin, United States Congressional Elections, 1788–1997: 208; Congressional Globe, House, 40th Cong., 3rd sess. (27 February 1869): 1684; House Committee of Elections, Simon Jones vs. James Mann, and Caleb S. Hunt vs. J. Willis Menard, 40th Cong., 3rd sess., H. Rept. 27 (1869).
301860 United States Federal Census, German, Darke, Ohio, M653, roll 956, page 200, National Archives and Record Administration, https://www.ancestrylibrary.com/; “From Dayton,” 29 June 1870, Cincinnati Daily Gazette: 3; “From Dayton,” 9 January 1871, Cincinnati Daily Gazette: 3; “Personal,” 20 January 1871, Chicago Tribune: 2; “We copy this complimentary notice of a recent appointee in the Louisianan,” 22 March 1872, New Orleans Republican: 5; Dubin, United States Congressional Elections, 1788–1997: 224; “Ravages of Yellow Fever in the South,” 29 September 1873, Baltimore Sun: 1; “Yellow Fever,” 27 September 1873, New Orleans Republican: 1.
31Philip Dray, Capitol Men: The Epic Story of Reconstruction Through the Lives of the First Black Congressmen (Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin Company, 2008): 103–104; Dubin, United States Congressional Elections, 1788–1997: 224; Senate Committee on Privileges and Elections, Report, 43rd Cong., 2nd sess., S. Rept. 626 (1875): 1; Congressional Record, House, 43rd Cong., 1st sess. (8 June 1874): 4701; Congressional Record, Appendix, 43rd Cong., 1st sess. (8 June 1874): 431–434; Foner, Reconstruction: 437, 550; House Committee on Elections, Sheridan vs. Pinchback, 43rd Cong., 2nd sess., H. Rept. 263 (1875); Congressional Record, Senate, 44th Cong., 1st sess. (8 March 1876): 1545–1558.
32Jeffrey A. Jenkins, “Partisanship and Contested Election Cases in the House of Representatives, 1789–1902,” Studies in American Political Development 18 (Fall 2004): 130.
33House Committee on Elections, Bowen vs. DeLarge, 42nd Cong., 3rd sess., H. Rept. 37 (1873); Congressional Globe, 42nd Cong., 3rd sess. (24 January 1873): 842–847.
34Congressional Record, House, 42nd Cong., 3rd sess. (29 January 1873): 949–952; House Committee on Elections, Silas L. Niblack vs. Josiah T. Walls, 42nd Cong., 3rd sess., H. Rept. 41 (1873); Congressional Record, House, 44th Cong., 1st sess. (19 April 1876): 2602; House Committee on Elections, Finley vs. Walls, 44th Cong., 1st sess., H. Rept. 295 (1876); Congressional Record, House, 44th Cong., 1st sess. (1 August 1876): 5051; House Committee on Elections, Bromberg vs. Haralson, 44th Cong., 1st sess., H. Rept. 294 (1876); House Committee on Elections, Lee vs. Rainey, 44th Cong., 1st sess., H. Rept. 578 (1876).
35Congressional Record, House, 45th Cong., 1st sess. (16 October 1877): 63, 65.
36House Committee on Elections, Witherspoon vs. Davidson, 47th Cong., 1st sess., H. Rept. 1278 (1882); Canter Brown, Florida’s Black Public Officials, 1867–1924 (Tuscaloosa: University of Alabama Press, 1998): 148; House Committee on Elections, O’Hara vs. Kitchin, 46th Cong., 3rd sess., H. Rept. 263 (1881), House Committee on Elections, Smalls vs. William Elliott, 50th Cong., 2nd sess., H. Rept. 3536 (1888); Dubin, United States Congressional Elections, 1788–1997: 284; House Committee on Elections, Miller vs. Elliott, 52nd Cong., 2nd sess., H. Rept. 2569 (1893); House Committee on Elections, Contested Election Case of Lynch vs. Chalmers, 47th Cong., 1st sess., H. Rept. 931 (1882); House Committee on Elections, Smalls vs. Tillman, 47th Cong., 1st sess., H. Rept. 1525 (1882); House Committee on Elections, John M. Langston vs. E.C. Venable, 51st Cong., 1st sess., H. Rept. 2462 (1890); House Committee on Elections, Miller vs. Elliott, 51st Cong., 1st sess., H. Rept. 2502 (1890); House Committee on Elections, No. 3, George W. Murray v. William Elliott, 54th Cong., 1st sess., H. Rept. 1567 (1896).
37Papers in the Case of Haralson vs. Shelley, 46th Cong., 1st sess., H. Misc. Doc. 25 (1879); Election Contest, Fourth District Alabama. Memorial of Jere Haralson, 46th Cong., 2nd sess., H. Misc. Doc. 19 (1880): 1–3; “Capitol Matters,” 27 January 1880, Washington Post: 1; “Telegraphic News,” 5 February 1880, Baltimore Sun: 1.