Representing Black Americans in the Nation’s Capital
Black Members of Congress arrived in Washington, DC, to find a thriving and expansive African-American community in the years following the Civil War. About 40,000 African Americans lived in the city after the war. Many had belonged to the large free Black population in the antebellum city, but many others had been formerly enslaved and sought refuge there following emancipation. In April 1862, Congress had passed the District of Columbia Emancipation Act, liberating enslaved Black Americans in the territory and providing monetary compensation to slaveholders. Black male suffrage was established within the District in 1867, and African Americans eagerly engaged with political affairs in the nation’s capital.38
About this object This detail of an 1889 Frank Leslie’s Illustrated Newspaper print documents the great interest of African Americans in observing Congress. Although the Capitol was not formally segregated, in practice the Visitors’ Gallery in both the House and Senate separated visitors by gender and race.
Beyond Capitol Hill, a vibrant Black political culture thrived in Washington, DC. Local newspapers reported on the commemorative events, political gatherings, fundraisers, lectures, and celebrations that often brought together African-American citizens and Members of Congress. Black Members were often asked to address dinner guests or assembled crowds in the District and nearby Baltimore. For example, in 1883, a local event celebrated the twentieth anniversary of the Emancipation Proclamation, with Frederick Douglass giving the keynote speech and former and current Black Members in attendance. Even small ceremonial occasions warranted the presence of Black lawmakers, such as the ceremony in which Representative Robert Smalls presented the Capital City Guard, a local Black militia company, with new rifles.40
Yet in many ways Washington remained a city closely linked to the customs of the old South. African Americans in Congress experienced discrimination in schools, theaters, restaurants, and hotels. In an 1874 newspaper interview, Joseph Rainey documented the second-class treatment he and his colleagues received in Washington. He noted that Black Representatives were “charged more for living than any of the white members” and were often forced to pay higher prices at local restaurants.41
Allies and Adversaries
On Capitol Hill, Black Members found a similar contradictory experience. They were often isolated and under the glare of public scrutiny as the press closely reported on their activities on the floor, frequently lacing their articles with racism and condescension. Some commended Black Members for forceful and effective speeches and noted when their arguments were well-received by those seated in the gallery. Others were exceedingly critical and fixated on the physical appearance of Black Members.
Among the overwhelmingly White membership of both houses of Congress, Black Members were generally received without incident. Some White Members went out of their way to ignore new Black Members of Congress. When Jefferson Long was sworn in as the second Black Representative, he was warmly greeted by Joseph Rainey, but not by his fellow lawmakers in the Georgia delegation. Republican colleagues were more likely to welcome Black Members in the House and Senate. Speaker James G. Blaine of Maine praised his Black colleagues in his memoirs. “They were as a rule, studious, earnest, ambitious men, whose public conduct,” Blaine emphasized, “would be honorable to any race.”42
About this object A six-term Representative from Virginia, John Thomas Harris belittled Black Members on the House Floor and opposed civil rights legislation in the 1870s.
Ransier’s bold response to Harris was an exception. More often, Black Members sought to engage the opposition in debate, if possible. A northern Democrat, New York Representative Samuel Sullivan “Sunset” Cox was consistently adversarial from the 1870s well into the 1890s. Representative George Frisbie Hoar of Massachusetts once noted that Black Members had in Cox “the most formidable antagonist, perhaps the most trained and experienced debater in the House.” Cox repeatedly challenged the words and motions of Black Representatives, issuing condescending remarks regarding their race and intelligence. Cox was antagonistic toward Rainey and others, offering patronizing remarks and false accusations to question the motives of the Republican Party and the ability of Black Members.44
Black Members benefited from the rules of each chamber to demonstrate their status as equals in Congress. Republican control of the House and the Senate afforded several Black Members the opportunity to preside over congressional proceedings during this period. On April 29, 1874, Speaker Blaine gave Rainey the honor of becoming the first Black Member to preside over the House. Rainey’s presence on the rostrum symbolized the pace of change on Capitol Hill at the time. “A Liberated Slave in the Speaker’s Chair,” the New York Herald wrote the day after Rainey presided during debate on an appropriations bill funding the Bureau of Indian Affairs. Nearly five years later, on February 14, 1879, Blanche Bruce became the first Black Senator to preside over that chamber during a debate on legislation to bar Chinese immigrants from the United States. The Chicago Tribune praised Bruce for presiding “with marked dignity and grace.”46
On January 11, 1883, Robert Smalls became the second Black Representative to preside over the House, doing so during debate on a bill to encourage and regulate American shipping. His experience was not extensively covered in the press, though one correspondent recorded a brief conversation between Smalls and a passenger on a Washington streetcar a few days later. The passenger was intent on praising the way Smalls preserved order in the proceedings from the rostrum. Smalls’s response hinted at the way the rules of the House had the potential to shape interactions between White and Black Members on the floor. Holding the gavel meant that Smalls had significant power but that he could only use it to reprimand those who violated the rules. “White men don’t like to be ordered by a colored man to be quiet,” Smalls noted. “That is why they kept quiet.” The House Rules ensured deference to the occupant of the rostrum during debate, but their jurisdiction ended at the chamber doors.47
Legislative Interests
Black lawmakers introduced measures designed to resolve pressing problems in their districts, facilitate public infrastructure development, and bring material improvements to the lives of their constituents. Ultimately, however, the small number of Black lawmakers in each Congress lacked the power to act collectively to drive legislation through each chamber. Most Black Members introduced bills in the House or the Senate only to have them die in committee. But when examined in aggregate, these proposals help illustrate their larger legislative agenda.
Members of Congress also received petitions and memorials which they entered into the Congressional Record. Some were related to relief on an individual basis, such as requests for monetary compensation or for the passage of particular legislation regarding an issue important in their congressional district or state. Those submitted by Black Members provide a window into the political agenda of Black communities across the nation during this period. They called for the funding of schools, new legislation important to a state or district, and federal action to defend African-American rights.49
Many of the measures introduced by Black Members addressed the interests of their congressional district. Black lawmakers sought ways to appropriate funds for infrastructure projects, such as public buildings, port expansion, and road and railroad development. Several introduced bills to create post offices. Black Members frequently tried to shape river and harbor bills, with the goal of allocating money to dredge shipping channels or for engineers to secure flood plains. In 1874, James Rapier proposed a bill to make the city of Montgomery, Alabama, a federal customs collections site and fund the salary of a customs collector. This was one of the few bills introduced by a Black Representative and successfully passed into law.50
Several Black Members recognized Congress’s vital role in commemorating historic places and events. In 1874, Rainey urged the House to provide funding for the preservation of Fort Sumter and Fort Moultrie in Charleston Harbor because of their significant “historical associations” with the Civil War. Josiah Walls spoke on the planning of the 1876 U.S. centennial celebration, describing the bonds of “common citizenship” that united the nation. Thomas E. Miller of South Carolina proposed a monument for Black Union soldiers in 1890. Henry Plummer Cheatham of North Carolina introduced two bills related to Black history in the 52nd Congress (1891–1893). The first authorized the publication of a history of African-American soldiers in the Civil War. He also proposed appropriating funds to produce a history of the “moral, intellectual, and industrial progress of the colored people of the United States of African descent” following the Emancipation Proclamation in 1863. Cheatham hoped to have this 30-year study exhibited at the highly-anticipated Chicago World’s Fair in 1893. Ultimately, however, none of these measures became law.51
Risky loans and questionable management practices, along with the financial panic of 1873, depleted the bank’s deposits, causing it to fail in 1874. Black Members, some of whom had invested in the bank themselves, attempted to intervene to secure payments to depositors, many of whom were at risk of losing their remaining savings. In 1875, Rainey spoke on the House Floor in defense of the interests of depositors, calling for a proper accounting of the bank’s assets and urging Congress to ensure its remaining liquidity was distributed properly.53
During the last decades of the nineteenth century, Black Members introduced legislation designed to provide relief to the bank’s depositors and distribute at least a portion of their savings. Even Michael Patrick O’Connor, a White Democrat from Beaufort, South Carolina—Robert Smalls’s hometown—introduced a bill for relief of the bank’s depositors in 1879, demonstrating the significance of this issue to Representatives serving districts with Black voters. None became law, however. Ultimately, few depositors received compensation despite repeated proposals from both Black and White Members.54
Committee Service
Black Members were assigned to a range of standing committees during this period but found few opportunities to drive a legislative agenda. Even during the early 1870s, when Black Members had Radical allies in the House, they did not receive assignments to the House’s most powerful committees, including Ways and Means, Judiciary, and Appropriations. The House and Senate committees with jurisdiction over education and labor were the most frequent appointments for Black Members. In the House, four Black Representatives served on the influential Agriculture Committee. The brevity of African-American careers during this era meant that they did not accumulate the seniority and influence needed to acquire the most desirable committee assignments.55
The collapse of the Freedman’s Bank resulted in two congressional investigations in which Black Members played significant roles in committee proceedings for the first time. In 1876, the House established a Select Committee on the Freedman’s Bank and assigned Rainey to the committee to help investigate why the bank failed and secure restitution for depositors. In accepting this position, Rainey became one of the first Black Members to fully participate in committee hearings as a panelist, directing pointed questions to witnesses to probe the basis of the bank’s collapse.56
Joseph Rainey earned accolades for his work on the Joint Committee on Enrolled Bills, where he collaborated with House clerks and his Senate colleagues to ensure accuracy in every measure considered by both chambers of Congress. The procedural expertise Rainey developed in this role was not a path to power on Capitol Hill, however. Where Congress’s true power lay—behind the closed doors of committee meetings and markup sessions—African-American Members, despite their tireless efforts, had limited influence and their legislative hopes were routinely left unfulfilled. In this way, Black Members shared a common experience with those of most Representatives and Senators with short careers on Capitol Hill. While middling committee assignments may have hindered the personal legislative agendas of most Black Members, debate on the House Floor offered the possibility for substantial contributions to significant legislation. Black Members seized these opportunities to act.58
Footnotes
38“The Census of 1870,” 8 July 1871, New York Times: 3; An Act for the Release of certain Persons held to Service or Labor in the District of Columbia, 12 Stat. 376 (1862); Kate Masur, An Example for All the Land: Emancipation and the Struggle over Equality in Washington, D.C. (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2010): 15, 138–146; An Act to regulate the elective Franchise in the District of Columbia, 14 Stat. 375 (1867).
39Office of the Historian, U.S. House of Representatives, “Discovering a Page’s Place in the ‘Second American Revolution,’ ” 21 February 2013, Whereas: Stories from the People’s House; Office of the Historian, U.S. House of Representatives, “The Appointment of William H. Smith as House Librarian.”
40“Reception to Colored Members of Congress,” 16 June 1874, Baltimore Sun: 1; “The Twentieth Anniversary of Lincoln’s Proclamation of Emancipation,” 6 January 1883, Washington Bee: 1; “Condensed Locals,” 26 January 1883, Evening Star: 5; Martin K. Gordon, “The Black Militia in the District of Columbia, 1867–1898,” Records of the Columbia Historical Society, Washington, D.C., vol. 71/72 (Washington, DC: Historical Society of Washington, D.C., 1971).
41Masur, An Example for All the Land: 230; “An Interview With A Colored Member,” 18 June 1874, New National Era: 2.
42“Another Colored Congressman,” 18 January 1871, Richmond Dispatch: 3; James G. Blaine, Twenty Years of Congress: From Lincoln to Garfield, vol. 2 (Norwich, CT: Henry Bill Publishing Co., 1886): 515.
43Congressional Record, House, 43rd Cong., 1st sess. (5 January 1874): 376.
44Congressional Record, House, 44th Cong., 1st sess. (15 July 1876): 4641–4644; Congressional Record, House, 44th Cong., 1st sess. (18 July 1876): 4707.
45Jones, Birthright Citizens: 34, 41–45; Congressional Record, House, 43rd Cong., 1st sess. (19 December 1873): 344; Congressional Record, House, 43rd Cong., 1st sess. (9 June 1874): 4782.
46“Our Washington Letter,” 8 May 1874, Jamestown Journal (NY): 4; Congressional Record, House, 43rd Cong., 1st sess. (29 April 1874): 3463–3477; “Washington,” 30 April 1874, New York Herald: 9; Congressional Record, Senate, 45th Cong., 2nd sess. (14 February 1879): 1306; “Ah Sin: The Chinese Debate in the Senate,” 15 February 1879, Chicago Daily Tribune: 1.
47Congressional Record, House, 47th Cong., 1st sess. (11 January 1883): 1108–1125; “A Colored Man in the Chair,” 12 January 1883, Indianapolis Journal: 2; “Why He Made a Good Presiding Officer,” 23 January 1883, Virginian-Pilot (Norfolk, VA): 3.
48Early House precedents indicate that the distinction between private and public legislation was at the determination of the Speaker of the House. House Manuals from the era define private legislation as “for the interest of individuals, public companies or corporations, a parish, city, or county, or other locality.” See, for example, Hinds Precedents of the House of Representatives, vol. 4 (Washington, DC: Government Printing Office, 1907): 247; Bureau of the Census, U.S. Department of Commerce, Historical Statistics of the United States, Colonial Times to 1970, Part 1 (Washington, DC: Government Printing Office, 1975): 1081–1082; Congressional Quarterly, Guide to Congress, 6th ed., vol. 1 (Washington, DC: Congressional Quarterly, Inc., 2008): 614–615; Luis-Alejandro Dinnella-Borrego, The Risen Phoenix: Black Politics in the Post-Civil War South (Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press, 2016): 68–70.
49Dinnella-Borrego, The Risen Phoenix: 70–71.
50An act to constitute Montgomery, in the State of Alabama, a port of delivery, 18 Stat. 196 (1874).
51Congressional Record, House, 43rd Cong., 1st sess. (12 February 1874): 1442–1443; Congressional Record, Appendix, 43rd Cong., 1st sess. (7 May 1874): 252; H.R. 12166, 51st Cong. (1890); H.R. 8982, 52nd Cong. (1892); H.R. 9021, 52nd Cong. (1892).
52Select Committee to Investigate the Freedman’s Savings and Trust Company, Report of the Select Committee to Investigate the Freedman’s Savings and Trust Company, 46th Cong., 2nd sess., S. Rept. 440 (1880): 263–264.
53Barbara P. Josiah, “Providing for the Future: The World of the African American Depositors of Washington, DC’s Freedmen’s Savings Bank, 1865–1874,” Journal of African American History 89, no. 1 (Winter 2004): 2; H.R. 4700, 43rd Cong. (1875); Congressional Record, House, 43rd Cong., 2nd sess. (3 March 1875): 2262–2263; Congressional Record, Appendix, 43rd Cong., 2nd sess. (2 March 1875): 184–185; Reginald Washington, “The Freedman’s Savings and Trust Company and African American Genealogical Research,” Prologue 29, no. 2 (1997): 170–181; Carl R. Osthaus, Freedmen, Philanthropy, and Fraud: A History of the Freedman’s Savings Bank (Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1976).
54H.R. 2500, 46th Cong. (1879); Washington, “The Freedman’s Savings and Trust Company and African American Genealogical Research”: 170–181.
55By the mid-nineteenth century, and especially in the post–Civil War era in the House, length of service began to determine committee hierarchy: the more terms in Congress, the higher the rank. But this process of centralization within the House evolved slowly and seniority did not become the primary determinant of committee hierarchy until the 1910s. Michael Aboam and Joseph Cooper, “The Rise of Seniority in the House of Representatives,” Polity 1 (Fall 1968): 52–84; Nelson Polsby, Miriam Gallaher, and Barry S. Rundquist, “The Growth of the Seniority System in the U.S. House of Representatives,” American Political Science Review 63 (September 1969): 787–807; Charles Stewart III, “Committee Hierarchies in the Modernizing House, 1875–1947,” American Journal of Political Science 36 (1992): 845–846.
56House Select Committee on the Freedman’s Bank, Freedman’s Bank, 44th Cong., 1st sess., H. Rept. 502 (1876).
57Congressional Record, Senate, 45th Cong., 1st sess. (9 March 1877): 39; “Senator Bruce’s Project,” 4 April 1879, New York Times: 1; “Telegraphic News From Washington,” 11 April 1879, Baltimore Sun: 1.
58Special Senate Committee, In the Senate of the United States, 45th Cong., 3rd sess., S. Rept. 784 (1879): 53; “A Busy Day in the House,” 25 February 1879, New York Times: 1; Congressional Record, House, 45th Cong., 3rd sess. (24 February 1879): 1872.