Whereas: Stories from the People’s House

From Representative to President: The House Career of James A. Garfield of Ohio

In May 1862, while stationed in eastern Kentucky, Brigadier General James A. Garfield began to receive encouragement from acquaintances back home in Ohio that he should pursue a seat in the U.S. House of Representatives. Five months earlier, Garfield had come to national prominence after he led a successful attack on Confederate forces at the Battle of Middle Creek, a crucial victory on the western theater.

Garfield in military uniform near the end of the Civil War/tiles/non-collection/1/10-27-Garfield-in-Uniform-LOC.xml Image courtesy of the Library of Congress James A. Garfield donned his Union Army uniform for this photograph taken near the conclusion of the Civil War.
For Garfield, the Civil War was a principled battle against slavery and disunion. While he aspired to rise through the ranks in the military, he was intrigued by the prospect of serving in the U.S. House. Ultimately, he heeded those calls to run in 1862 and entered the Republican primary in Ohio’s Nineteenth Congressional District, challenging the two-term incumbent, John Hutchins. Like many candidates running for Congress at the time, Garfield refused to campaign actively, but with help from friends in the district, he secured the nomination in September. He easily won the general election in November, benefitting from the overwhelmingly Republican electorate.

Garfield would not take his seat until the House convened for the 38th Congress (1863–1865) in December 1863, and instead of resigning from the Army, he remained in the military for nearly 13 more months. In September, his dramatic ride to the front lines at the Battle of Chickamauga earned him a promotion to Major General and was celebrated in the press. Garfield even considered declining his seat in Congress to remain in the military, but President Abraham Lincoln personally convinced him that his party could not afford another vacancy in the House.

On December 7, 1863, Garfield was sworn in less than a week after the final section of the Statue of Freedom was hoisted atop the Capitol dome. Re-elected eight times, the Ohio Representative’s 17-year career on Capitol Hill overlapped with an unprecedented period of growth in the powers and scope of the federal government. As a Civil War veteran, Garfield helped set the GOP’s agenda during the political battles over Reconstruction. He played an influential role on several House committees, including two terms as chair of the Appropriations Committee, a relatively new panel that grew in influence under Garfield’s stewardship. Before the emergence of elected party leadership in the House, Garfield also directed House Republicans’ legislative agenda during parts of three Congresses from 1876 to 1880, when he was elected President. Garfield’s wealth of experience made him well-prepared to become the first and to this date only Member of the House elected directly to the presidency.

Log Cabin childhood home of James A. Garfield/tiles/non-collection/1/10-27-Garfield-Childhood-Home-OhioHistoryConnection.xml Image courtesy of Ohio History Connection James A. Garfield spent his childhood in a log cabin in Orange Township, Ohio. A replica of the cabin was constructed in what is now Moreland Hills in 1999.

Early Life

Born on November 19, 1831, James Abram Garfield grew up in Orange township in Ohio’s Cuyahoga County. His father died when he was two years old and his family struggled to run a small farm. As a teenager, Garfield drove the teams of horses that pulled boats up and down the canals carrying goods through northeastern Ohio to Lake Erie. His time on the canal was cut short by illness, and while recovering his mother encouraged him to pursue an education.

James A. Garfield in 1848/tiles/non-collection/1/10-27-Young-James-Garfield-OhioHistoryConnection.xml Image courtesy of the Ohio History Connection This photograph shows the future president shortly after he left home at age 16. While attending Geauga Seminary in Chester Township, Ohio, Garfield met Lucretia Randolph, and the couple married a decade later.
Garfield attended several schools before finding a place at the Western Reserve Eclectic Institute in Hiram, Ohio, where he cleaned the campus grounds to pay for tuition. He went on to study at Williams College in western Massachusetts, graduating in 1856 before returning to Ohio to teach and later serve as the principal of the Eclectic. Elected to the Ohio state senate in 1859—his first public office—Garfield began studying law and was admitted to the bar in 1861.

Ohio’s “Gallant Soldier-Statesman”

On Capitol Hill, “General Garfield,” as many in the press called him after he arrived in Washington straight from the front lines, was a steadfast Radical Republican and used his wartime experiences to speak authoritatively on the conflict and military matters. In his first major speech on the House Floor in early 1864, Garfield argued for the government’s constitutional right to confiscate and sell the property of Confederate rebels. “I represent the Army of the Republic on this floor,” Garfield thundered, before outlining legal arguments in favor of the policy. Confiscation was “a war right,” Garfield noted, and the precedent had been set by the Continental Congress during the American Revolution, which encouraged the seizure of loyalist property. To defeat the Confederacy, the federal government must “take away its chief prop, slavery and landed estates.”

During his early years in the House, Garfield’s main committee assignment was on Military Affairs. He worked closely with chair Robert Cumming Schenck of Ohio, who often let Garfield lead the committee’s business. By the time of his first re-election in 1864, Garfield’s record during his initial term led the New-York Daily Tribune to praise him as a “gallant soldier-statesman” worthy of renomination.

James A. Garfield Monument on the Cover of Harper's Weekly Magazine/tiles/non-collection/1/10-27-Harpers-Weekly-Statues-2005_218_1.xml Collection of the U.S. House of Representatives
About this object
The Garfield Monument was unveiled on the grounds of the U.S. Capitol in 1887; the event was marked on the cover of Harper's Weekly magazine in this hand-colored wood engraving.
Following the assassination of President Abraham Lincoln and the installation of Vice President Andrew Johnson in the White House, the Republican-controlled Congress struggled to set the terms of Reconstruction following the conclusion of the war. Johnson favored a far more lenient policy toward former Confederates than the Radicals, which strained relations between the White House and Capitol Hill. For his part, Garfield declared that Congress had “capacious powers” to determine the postwar future of the South. In a February 1866 speech, he urged lawmakers to protect the civil and political rights of individuals in the South, including formerly enslaved Black Americans. “The spirit of slavery is still among us,” he warned, “it must be utterly destroyed before we shall feel safe.”

Garfield’s first major legislative achievement created a role for the federal government in education. In 1866, he was named chair of a select committee charged with crafting a bill to establish a Department of Education to collect statistics and share information with schools across the nation. This investment in education, he said, was essential, as “our system of government is based upon the intelligence of the people.” In 1867, Garfield’s bill initially failed in the House, but his efforts to corral votes resulted in its passage on a second vote. The new agency had limited powers and resources, however, and was soon reorganized as the Bureau of Education within the U.S. Department of the Interior.

On Capitol Hill, Garfield also continued his lifelong pursuit of learning. He read widely, including fiction and nonfiction, often making time late in the evenings after a long day of work. The Librarian of Congress, Ainsworth Rand Spofford, noted that Garfield requested books more frequently than his House colleagues. Garfield also wrote essays on American history and congressional procedure in notable publications including The Atlantic Monthly and the North American Review. In 1876, he even found time to publish an original mathematical proof of the Pythagorean theorem in the New England Journal of Education.

The U.S. House of Representatives acquired this portrait of Garfield in 1891, ten years after his assassination, to honor his chairmanship of the Appropriations Committee./tiles/non-collection/1/10-27-Garfield-Portrait-2002_006_006.xml Collection of the U.S. House of Representatives
About this object
The U.S. House of Representatives acquired this portrait of Garfield in 1891, ten years after his assassination, to honor his chairmanship of the Appropriations Committee.

The Committee Chairman

In 1865, at the start of his second term, Garfield was assigned to the Ways and Means Committee, the powerful tax-writing panel. Heading into the 40th Congress (1867–1869), he appealed to party leadership to become chair of Ways and Means but instead departed the panel entirely when he was given the chairmanship of the Military Affairs Committee.

In the 41st Congress (1869–1871), Garfield was named chair of the Banking and Currency Committee where he led an investigation into the September 1869 financial panic that followed attempts by several Wall Street financiers to manipulate the price of gold. He spearheaded the development of a currency bill in the House designed to reform the nation’s fragile banking system and increase the circulation of bank notes instead of greenbacks—paper money distributed during the Civil War and not backed by gold or silver. He served as one of the House managers of the bill when it went to a conference committee with the Senate and became law in 1870.

Garfield accomplished his most significant work on the Appropriations Committee, which the House established in 1865 to handle Congress’s government funding responsibilities. In two terms as chair beginning in the 42nd Congress (1871–1873), Garfield revolutionized the structure and priorities of the panel.

"Farmer Garfield Cutting a Swath to the White House" Pro-Garfield Poster/tiles/non-collection/1/10-27-Farmer-Garfield-OhioHistoryConnection.xml Image courtesy of the Ohio History Connection This pro-Garfield presidential campaign poster, published by Currier & Ives in 1880, imagined the candidate as a heroic and pastoral figure, cutting through a field of vices choking America on his way to the White House.
For Garfield, the United States government was a “vast Colossus” that had grown exponentially in the nineteenth century. Money, he said, was the “motive power” animating the government, and it was the responsibility of the Appropriations Committee to wisely employ the resources of the U.S. Treasury. Garfield cautioned Members who only called for cuts to federal spending, reminding his colleagues that money for public works, including rivers and harbors projects and the construction of lighthouses along the coast, should be considered “investments for the comfort, convenience, and growth of the nation.” Garfield also suggested the House create a committee to draft an annual budget to connect revenues and expenditures—decades before the federal government was required by law to do so in 1921.

As Appropriations chair, Garfield charged his committee with scrutinizing and improving the 12 funding bills Congress had to pass for each fiscal year. To ensure each draft was studied closely, he assigned one bill to each member of the panel—even to Democrats in the minority. The annual review of spending bills, Garfield noted, could save the government money by placing expenditures “where they ought to have been brought long ago, under the immediate eye of the people through their representatives in Congress.”

For Garfield, the federal government’s collection and disbursement of funds was crucial to understanding America’s values. “If our republic were blotted from the earth and from the memory of mankind,” Garfield asserted, leaving behind only the revenue and spending bills from one year, “the political philosopher would be able from these materials alone to reconstruct a large part of our history, and sketch with considerable accuracy the character and spirit of our institutions.”

Electoral Commission meeting by candlelight in secret session/tiles/non-collection/1/10-27-Electoral-Commission-LOC.xml Image courtesy of the Library of Congress This image, which appeared in Frank Leslie’s Illustrated Newspaper on March 10, 1877, shows the Electoral Commission meeting by candle light in the Old Supreme Court Chamber in the Capitol.

Republican Leader

When the House convened for the opening of the 44th Congress (1875–1877) in December 1875, the Democratic Party returned to the majority for the for the first time since before the Civil War. Garfield continued to serve on the Rules Committee and returned to the Ways and Means Committee. After Representative James G. Blaine of Maine departed for the Senate in 1876, Garfield was effectively the Republican leader in the House—although the formal, elected party leadership role did not exist at the time. In January 1877, he was also one of five Representatives named to the Electoral Commission which settled the dispute over the results of the 1876 presidential election in favor of Republican candidate Rutherford B. Hayes of Ohio.

In 1879, Garfield played a key role in a battle over appropriations in the House when the Democratic majority tried to attach “riders” to spending bills in the 46th Congress (1879–1881). These riders were non-spending provisions designed to change laws related to Reconstruction in the South, including efforts to roll back federal supervision of elections in the former Confederacy. Garfield called the maneuver a “revolutionary method of legislation by coercion” that would result in “the total subversion of this Government.” He accused Democrats of reviving the spirit of the Confederacy, aiming to “starve the Government to death” to accomplish what they could not win on the battlefield. President Hayes vetoed the appropriations bills containing riders, which prompted the Democrats to mount four attempts to override the President. Garfield worked closely with the President to mobilize the votes to sustain each veto before Democrats removed the riders.

President Garfield's Inauguration/tiles/non-collection/1/10-27-Garfield-Inauguration-LOC.xml Image courtesy of the Library of Congress Chief Justice Morrison R. Waite administered the oath of office to President James A. Garfield on the east portico of the U.S. Capitol on March 4, 1881.

From the Capitol to the White House

On January 13, 1880, the Ohio state legislature elected Garfield to the U.S. Senate for the term slated to begin in 1881. Six months later, at the Republican National Convention in Chicago, unprecedented events steered him away from the Senate and towards the White House.

On June 8, 1880, Garfield emerged as the party’s surprise presidential nominee on the thirty-sixth ballot, besting former President Ulysses S. Grant and Senator James G. Blaine of Maine. After a campaign that called for civil service reform and warned of corrupt business influences within government, Garfield was elected President of the United States on November 2, 1880. He resigned from the House less than a week later and was inaugurated as the twentieth President on March 4, 1881.

Attack on President Garfield in Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper/tiles/non-collection/1/10-27-Attack-Frank-Leslie-LOC.xml Image courtesy of the Library of Congress The immediate aftermath of the attack against President Garfield was captured in this cover image of Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper on July 16, 1881.
Although he was elected to the highest office in the land, Garfield reserved particular praise for the legislative branch. A keen student of history, he reflected on the origins and development of Congress in the pages of The Atlantic Monthly on the occasion of the 1876 Centennial.

For Garfield, “the history of liberty and union in this country, as developed by the men of 1776 and maintained by their successors, is inseparably connected with the history of the national legislature.” Congress and its “many striking characters and many stirring scenes,” he wrote, served as a crucible for debate and provided direction to the federal government. “Congress has always been and must always be the theatre of contending opinions; the forum where the opposing forces of political philosophy meet to measure their strength; where the public good must meet the assaults of local and sectional interests; in a word, the appointed place where the nation seeks to utter its thought and register its will.”

On July 2, 1881, Garfield was shot in the back by an assassin as he waited for a train in Washington, DC. He endured a long, painful convalescence before his death on September 19, 1881. Garfield lay in state in the Capitol Rotunda several days later. The House of Representatives never convened during his brief presidency.

Sources: Congressional Globe, House, 38th Cong., 1st sess. (28 January 1864): 403–405; Congressional Globe, Appendix, 39th Cong., 1st sess. (1 February 1866) 64–69; Congressional Globe, House, 39th Cong., 1st sess. (14 February 1866): 846; Congressional Globe, House, 39th Cong., 1st sess. (8 June 1866): 3049–3051; Congressional Globe, House, 39th Cong., 1st sess. (19 June 1866): 3269–3270; Congressional Globe, House, 40th Cong., 2nd sess. (15 May 1868): 2480–2487; Congressional Globe, House, 41st Cong., 2nd sess. (28 June 1870): 4948–4950; Congressional Record, House, 43rd Cong., 1st sess. (5 March 1874): 1997–2005; Congressional Record, House, 43rd Cong., 1st sess. (23 June 1874): 5435–5438; Congressional Record, House, 46th Cong., 1st sess. (29 March 1879): 115–118; House Committee on Banking and Currency, Gold Panic Investigation, 41st Cong., 2nd sess. H. Rept. 31 (1870); H.R. 276, 39th Cong. (1866); H.R. 1900, 41st Cong. (1870); S. 378, 41st Cong. (1870); An Act to establish a Department of Education, 14 Stat. 434 (1867); 16 Stat. 251 (1870); Budget and Accounting Act of 1921, Public Law 67-13, 42 Stat. 20 (1921); New-York Daily Tribune, 23 August 1864; James A. Garfield, “The Currency Crisis,” The Atlantic Monthly 37 (February 1876): 219–236; “Pons Asinorum,” New England Journal of Education 3, no. 14 (1 April 1876): 161; James A. Garfield, “A Century of Congress,” The Atlantic Monthly 40 (July 1877): 49–64; James A. Garfield, “National Appropriations and Misappropriations,” North American Review 128, no. 271 (June 1879): 572–586; A.G. Riddle, The Life, Character, and Public Services of Jas. A. Garfield (New York: F.S. Bogue, 1880): 196–197; C.W. Goodyear, President Garfield: From Radical to Unifier (New York: Simon & Schuster, 2023); Candice Millard, Destiny of the Republic: A Tale of Madness, Medicine and the Murder of a President (New York: Anchor Books, 2011); Allan Peskin, Garfield (1978; repr., Kent, OH: Kent State University Press, 1998); Frank P. Vazzano, “President Hayes, Congress, and the Appropriations Riders Vetoes,” Congress & the Presidency 20, no. 1 (Spring 1993): 25–37; Office of the Secretary of the Senate, Presidential Vetoes, 1789–1976 (Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office: 1978).