A Level Playing Field? Congress Tackles Football's Antitrust Problem
On August 28, 1961, a crowd gathered in room 346 of the Old House Office Building—what is today the Cannon House Office Building—for a hearing scheduled by the Antitrust Subcommittee of the Committee on the Judiciary. Outside the weather was typical for late summer in Washington, DC, with temperatures approaching 90 degrees. Inside the hearing room, however, thoughts turned to September, when cooler weather and shorter days would signify the start of a new season. Fall—and football—were on the horizon.
Both collegiate and professional football were slated to begin their respective seasons in September amid a surge in popularity for the sport. A few months earlier, the National Football League (NFL) announced that its season would kick off on Sunday, September 17, with Minnesota’s new expansion franchise, the Vikings, playing its first game. The NFL also announced that it had lengthened the 1961 season by requiring each team to play 14 games. College football, meanwhile, would begin a day before the NFL, with several matchups slated for Saturday, September 16.
/tiles/non-collection/8/8-26-Celler-Portrait-2002_012_005.xml
Collection of the U.S. House of Representatives
About this object
In August 1961, Emanuel Celler, chair of the Antitrust Subcommittee of the Committee on the Judiciary, held a hearing on the telecasting of professional sports contests.
By 1961, fans of college and professional football who could not attend games in person expected to be able to watch their local teams play on television. But whether anyone would be able to watch those games in the future remained to be seen. For years, each individual NFL team had negotiated a broadcast deal with a regional carrier. In April 1961, however, the NFL signed a nationwide contract with the Columbia Broadcasting System (CBS) with exclusive rights to televise its games starting with the 1962 season. But in the summer of 1961, a federal judge ruled that the NFL had violated antitrust laws by negotiating directly with CBS.
House Judiciary Chairman Emanuel Celler and his committee responded by opening an investigation into whether the NFL—and by extension, other professional sports leagues—had the right to set up their own big broadcast deals. As they broached the issue of television rights, however, other questions emerged. If the NFL was permitted to negotiate an exclusive contract, would the league be allowed to broadcast its games every day of the week or did the NFL plan on sticking to Sundays? Could college football compete with professional football if games were scheduled on the same day? Amid the NFL’s growth in popularity, just how much influence, Celler’s subcommittee asked, was too much influence?
“It Will Be the Players and Fans Who Will Benefit Most from This Bonanza”
In the spring of 1961, few individuals anticipated the fallout from the announcement that the NFL and CBS had reached a television deal. For many, it seemed like a step forward.
/tiles/non-collection/8/8-26-Pete-Rozelle-White-House-LBJ.xml
Courtesy of the LBJ Presidential Library
In the 1960s, NFL Commissioner Pete Rozelle (third from left) worked closely with Congress and the White House to grow the game of football.
Critics argued that under the old system, in which each team was responsible for its own television deal, profit was distributed unequally throughout the league; teams in larger markets often had more leverage to demand more lucrative contracts. Supporters of the NFL’s new arrangement with CBS embraced its potential to even the playing field. NFL commissioner Pete Rozelle stressed that each team would receive equal profits from the deal, and he believed that the new system would “help us keep our equality of competition.” Other observers saw this new arrangement as a net positive, as well. “It will be the players and fans who will benefit most from this bonanza that has culminated the NFL’s rising popularity in the past 15 years,” one newspaper noted.
Whether the deal was legal, however, was another question entirely. On July 20, 1961, Allan Grim, a federal judge on the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, ruled that the contract violated existing antitrust laws. Grim thought that each team should retain the right to negotiate the most profitable contract that it could with the carrier of its choice. Grim’s ruling caused consternation not only to the NFL, but to commissioners of other professional sports leagues who had similar television contracts—including the American Football League, the NFL’s smaller rival, which had signed a television deal in 1960 with the American Broadcasting Company (ABC).
/tiles/non-collection/8/8-26-Kemp-Trading-Card-2007_081_000.xml
Collection of the U.S. House of Representatives
Celler’s legislation ensured that football fans would have plenty of viewing options each fall. They were thus in no danger of missing a young quarterback named Jack Kemp lead the San Diego Chargers to the AFL championship game in December 1961.
“On a Day Other Than Sunday”
Faced with the sudden possibility that Grim’s ruling would prevent the broadcast of NFL games in 1962, legislators acted quickly to prevent what they feared would be a nationwide blackout. On August 16, 1961, Senator Carey Estes Kefauver of Tennessee introduced S. 2427 to provide sports leagues with an exemption to federal antitrust laws enabling them to negotiate league-wide television contracts. Hoping to protect collegiate football’s viewership, which mostly occurred on Saturdays, Kefauver’s bill also included specific language that all but limited professional football to being broadcast on Sundays.
The following day, Celler introduced his own measure in the House. Celler was an authority on antitrust legislation and wanted to lead the push to amend the existing laws. On August 17, he introduced H.R. 8757. The bill was simple and stated that professional “football, baseball, basketball, or hockey” leagues had the right to sell their collective television rights.
Both the NFL and CBS were pleased at the swift response in Congress. In a public statement, Rozelle praised Kefauver and Celler, noting “prompt passage of appropriate legislation at this session of Congress would enable the NFL to prevent a situation starting in 1962 wherein approximately half of the 14 clubs would be without television.”
Building a Competitive League
Eleven days after Celler submitted his bill, Rozelle attended the late-August Antitrust Subcommittee hearing in the Old House Office Building, testifying in support of Celler’s legislation. In his opening statement, Rozelle thanked Celler for his “prompt action” and said that his bill was “essential to the continued successful operation of the National Football League.”
Rozelle focused on the economic realities facing NFL teams. In the 1950s, gridiron success had not guaranteed profitability. He pointed to the example of the Baltimore Colts, who, he said, had “sold out their stadium for every game” en route to winning a second championship. The Colts were successful on the field and yet would have “lost money in 1959 without radio-TV income,” Rozelle pointed out.
He also argued that a collective television contract ensured that smaller-market teams would gain access to the same income as large-market teams. To illustrate this, he singled out the Green Bay Packers and New York Giants. “The Green Bay Packers, representing a community of some 63,000 people, were to receive the same amount of television income as the New York Giants, located in an area of over 8 million people.”
/tiles/non-collection/8/8-26-McCulloch-Blotter-2016_044_004-000.xml
Collection of the U.S. House of Representatives, Gift of Matthew S. Dole
About this object
William Moore McCulloch of Ohio attended the hearing and worried about how the legislation would impact his alma mater: Ohio State. He hoped that Congress would protect Saturdays for college football.
“That Great Sporting Event on Saturday Afternoons”
At the hearing, lawmakers peppered Rozelle with questions concerning college football. If the NFL was granted additional antitrust exemptions, would it use that power to schedule games on Saturday? Lawmakers did not think that colleges, which often had local television contracts, could compete with professional leagues. William Moore McCulloch of Ohio worried about the future of the Ohio State University football team and wanted assurances that any legislation would not damage the popularity of college football. “I hope it is possible,” McCulloch remarked, “that the legislation which we are considering will not in any way impinge upon that great sporting event on Saturday afternoons particularly.”
/tiles/non-collection/8/8-26-Puck-College-World-LC.xml
Courtesy of the Library of Congress
In the twentieth century, the popularity of college football steadily increased, with Saturdays being set aside for games on campuses across the nation.
As the hearing progressed, unusual alliances formed within the committee. Representative
George Meader of Ann Arbor, Michigan—home to the University of Michigan Wolverines and chief rival of the Ohio State Buckeyes within the Big Ten Conference—adopted a similar position to McCulloch. Addressing Rozelle, Meader noted he was “very sensitive to the interests of universities, the Big Ten, and college athletics generally.” Like McCulloch, Meader worried that the House measure did not adequately protect college football or prevent the NFL from broadcasting on Saturdays.
While Rozelle insisted that the NFL had no interest in scheduling contests on Saturdays, he opposed the “sweeping language” of the Senate measure, which, he said, provided “college priority” on every day but Sunday. During the hearing, Celler offered his own criticism of the Senate bill, pointing out its impracticability in his home state of New York. There were so many colleges near the NFL’s New York Giants and the AFL’s New York Titans (which later became the New York Jets) that it would make scheduling impossible. He noted that you would “have to have an army to be able to find out the schedules of all these colleges and universities.”
“This Precludes Viewing Choice by the Public”
/tiles/non-collection/8/8-26-Football-Minded-PA2019_01_0053.xml
Collection of the U.S. House of Representative
Even before the rise of television, Members of the House of Representatives kept up on the happenings in the football world. On January 2, 1939, Speaker of the House William Bankhead (portfolio under arm), listened to a college football game, along with Andrew Edmiston, John Kee, Joe L. Smith, Jennings Randolph and George W. Johnson.
Not everyone thought that the NFL should be permitted to negotiate a television contract on behalf of individual teams. Vincent T. Wasilewski, the vice president for government affairs for the National Association of Broadcasters, also testified before Celler’s subcommittee. Wasilewski hoped that Congress would abide by Grim’s ruling. “Our first major objection to this bill goes to the fact that it authorizes a league to make one contract for the rights of all of its games,” Wasilewski protested. “This precludes viewing choice by the public because it would exclude others from obtaining telecasting rights from individual clubs.”
Wasilewski also disagreed with several of the NFL’s claims about the benefits of the proposed legislation. Was there evidence that an exclusive television contract would help level the playing field for smaller-market teams? he asked. Throughout Wasilewski’s testimony, lawmakers peppered him with questions, but he kept returning to his main point: that granting the NFL the power to negotiate an exclusive contract with a network would ultimately result in there being fewer viewing options for football fans each weekend.
“A Bill that Recognizes the Interests of All”
Celler took the criticisms leveled by Wasilewski and others seriously and on September 18, 1961, he introduced a revised bill, H.R. 9096. The new legislation protected high school and collegiate football by banning “the telecasting of all or a substantial part of any professional football game on any Friday after six o’clock postmeridian or on any Saturday during the period beginning on the second Friday in September and ending on the second Saturday in December in any year from any telecasting station located within seventy-five miles of the game site of any intercollegiate football contest schedule to be played on such a date.” Celler said the new bill “recognizes the interests of all” and had the backing of Rozelle as well as the commissioners of Major League Baseball and the American Football League.
/tiles/non-collection/8/8-26-Kennedy-Coin-Toss-JFK.xml
Courtesy of the John F. Kennedy Presidential Library and Museum
Celler’s legislation passed the House and the Senate and was signed into law by President John F. Kennedy on September 30, 1961.
The bill’s precise language satisfied fans of professional and collegiate football in Congress. Representative
Charles Abraham Halleck of Indiana produced letters of support from the director of athletics at both Indiana University and Purdue University. Halleck thanked Celler and his committee “for having worked out a satisfactory solution to a very difficult situation” and for “protecting collegiate athletics.”
Horace Robinson Kornegay of North Carolina also expressed his support. While his constituents enjoyed watching Washington’s professional football team on Sunday, they were “mightily interested in preserving the rights and privileges of our wonderful intercollegiate teams to appear on the television screens on Friday night and Saturday.”
H.R. 9096 passed the House and the Senate and was signed into law by President John F. Kennedy on September 30, 1961. The legislation ensured that fans could anticipate long weekends in the fall filled with televised football. “When the 1962 professional season dawns sometime next September, Mr. T.V. Fan will have the choice of watching the best professional games of the week, be they NFL or AFL,” one sportswriter predicted.
Over the long term, Celler’s legislation changed how America’s football leagues scheduled games. In his testimony, Rozelle discussed the NFL’s future plans: “Perhaps Wednesday or Wednesday night football will be played 20 years from now,” Rozelle optimistically predicted. Nine years later, on September 21, 1970, the NFL introduced Monday night football, a scheduling change that became something of a cultural phenomenon. Thursday night football was added later. Celler’s H.R. 9096 ensured that Saturdays remained the domain of college football, at least from the “second Friday in September” to the “second Saturday in December.” But it also enabled the NFL to gradually expand past Sundays.
Sources: Congressional Record, House, 87 Cong., 1st sess. (18 September 1961): 20061–20063; Hearing before the Antitrust Subcommittee (Subcommittee No. 5) of the Committee on the Judiciary, Telecasting of Professional Sports Contests, 87th Cong., 1st. sess. (1961); A Bill to amend the antitrust laws to authorize needs of professional football, baseball, basketball, and hockey teams to enter into certain television contracts, and for other purposes, S. 2427, 87th Cong. (1961); A Bill to amend the antitrust laws to authorize leagues of professional football, baseball, basketball, and hockey teams to enter into certain television contracts, and for other purposes, H.R. 8757, 87th Cong. (1961); An Act to amend the antitrust laws to authorize leagues of professional football, baseball, basketball, and hockey teams to enter into certain television contracts, and for other purposes, H.R. 9096, 87th Cong. (1961); An Act to amend the antitrust laws to authorize leagues of professional football, baseball, basketball, and hockey teams to enter into certain television contracts, and for other purposes, H.R. 9096, 87th Cong. (1961); An Act to amend the antitrust laws to authorize leagues of professional football, baseball, basketball, and hockey teams to enter into certain television contracts, and for other purposes, Public Law 87-331, 75 Stat. 732 (1961); United States v. National Football League, 196 F. Supp. 445 (E.D. Pa. 1961); Alabama Journal, 21 July 1961; Albuquerque Journal, 27 April 1961; Carlsbad Current-Argus (New Mexico), 1 October 1961; Courier-Post (Camden, NJ), 18 August 1961; Herald News (Fall River, MA), 12 April 1961; Plain Dealer, 24 September 1961; Racine Journal-Times (Wisconsin), 24 September 1961; Springfield Republican, 7 May 1961; Springfield Union, 21 September 1970; Tampa Times, 7 August 1961; Tyler Morning Telegraph, 30 November 2006; Washington Daily News, 28 August 1961.