A Tale of Two Studios
Why does the House Collection have so many photographs of multiple, surprisingly amateurish studio sets? The images are all obviously staged, and each one shows a Member of Congress at a desk in a faux office with an unconvincing view of the Capitol.
It turns out that for decades, Members trooped to one of two photography studios in the House. One was for Republicans, and the other for Democrats. They worked in adjacent spaces but reportedly did not share equipment or even pleasantries. Nonetheless, the two backdrops had the same general feel. Each one was dressed to look like a congressional office, with a desk, chair, and window looking out onto a photograph of the Capitol. What’s more, although the photographs from both studios were in color, the view through the window is in black and white.
In the 1960s and 1970s, Representatives went to the studios to have official pictures taken. The portraits usually became postcards, printed on the reverse with folksy messages for the voters back home. The images all seem similar, but close scrutiny reveals the differences between the two stage sets. In addition, each studio’s attempt at trendy accessories took slightly different turns. Take a closer look at some of the magnificent mid-century décor.
The Republicans’ Studio
/tiles/non-collection/5/5-3-studio-sets-Henderson-2013_061_000.xml
John Earl Henderson palm card, Collection of the U.S. House of Representatives
The oldest known photograph of the Republicans’ imitation office shows a 1958 symphony in blue. The bookshelves, curtains, upholstery, and desk are blue.
John Henderson, nattily attired in a blue suit, matches the decorations perfectly. Close at hand on the desk blotter are a few books, a big glass ashtray tucked in one corner, and a big black telephone. Several of these props show up in later photos, often with the curtains parted to show the false window looking onto a false Capitol.
/tiles/non-collection/5/5-3-studio-sets-Ford-2017_039_000.xml
Gerald Rudolph Ford Jr. postcard, Collection of the U.S. House of Representatives
At around the same time, future President
Gerald Ford came in for a desk shot. The setup was the same as in John Henderson’s postcard, but in this vertical view, the curtain valance is visible at the top of the frame. Its symmetrical, curving shape was common in interiors that aspired to the well-known, patriotic Colonial Revival feel. It is no surprise that Congress incorporated a similar design, too.
The Democrats’ Set
/tiles/non-collection/5/5-3-studio-sets-Jennings-2015_033_000.xml
William Pat Jennings postcard, Collection of the U.S. House of Representatives
Meanwhile in 1960, over in the Democrats’ photo studio, right next door to the Republicans’ shop, the open curtains reveal a massive black-and-white photograph of the Capitol behind the mullioned window. This, the earliest known photograph of the Democrats’ office stage, shows that the shelves and the basic setup were the same as in Henderson’s and Ford’s photos, but the accessories differed. There is a smaller green phone rather than a black one, a brown desk rather than a blue one, and a set of hefty books—
Land, a
Congressional Directory,
Soil, the House Rules, and a Bible, held up by donkey bookends, a symbol of the Democratic Party. Congressman
Pat Jennings added the Virginia state flag, and perhaps brought his own messy pile of papers.
/tiles/non-collection/5/5-3-studio-sets-Holifield-2006_028_000.xml
Chester Earl Holifield postcard, Collection of the U.S. House of Representatives
A few years later, in 1964, photo set desks got more crowded. This postcard sent by
Chet Holifield to his constituents is a high-water mark of congressional accessorizing. The green phone, the desk blotter, and the fountain pen remain from earlier photos. Holifield’s also has a nameplate, a desk calendar, eight books, copies of the
Congressional Record, a gavel, and sleeker bookends. The office gewgaws help distract from the right side of the image, where the set’s dressing gives way to the tattered temporary wall.
/tiles/non-collection/5/5-3-studio-sets-Sullivan-2007_269_000.xml
Leonor Kretzer Sullivan postcard, Collection of the U.S. House of Representatives
Sets did not change much from the earliest postcards in 1958 through the 1960s, beyond the ebb and flow of desktop flotsam. The photographs of the Capitol occasionally changed, most likely an update after the major renovation of the East Front façade. In the 1970s, however, both the Democratic and Republican studios redecorated. Out went the blue, and in came the era’s beloved harvest gold and brown.
Leonor Sullivan’s 1976 postcard also shows the newly streamlined window frame and desk, which, along with the tight focus of the camera, makes a more plausible likeness of an office. The element that truly makes Sullivan’s photograph convincing is the Capitol photograph, at long last in color. The Republicans updated their set at about the same time, making similar color and backdrop choices.
A Bipartisan Fake Office
/tiles/non-collection/5/5-3-studio-sets-Lewis-PA2016_01_0034b.xml
John R. Lewis photograph, Collection of the U.S. House of Representatives
The House’s two
photography outfits combined in the 1980s, knocking down the wall between their offices. The question arose: would both office sets survive? Desk postcards went out of fashion in the 1980s, but photos of two new lawmakers, standing rather than sitting, give some clues to the sets’ fate. In one ca. 1987 photo,
John Lewis stands behind the desk. In another, taken around the same time, Republican
Ileana Ros-Lehtinen stands before the same backdrop, but at a lectern instead of a desk.
/tiles/non-collection/5/5-3-studio-sets-Ros-Lehtinen-PA2022_02_0008c.xml
Ileana Ros-Lehtinen photograph, Collection of the U.S. House of Representatives
Close examination of the curtains, window frame, and image of the Capitol reveal that they were salvaged from the Democrats’ backdrop, while the chair is from the Republican studio. The Democrats’ set and Republicans’ furniture became the version used for all Members, joining at last both sides of the aisle in one fake office.
Sources: “Analysis of House Photography Studio Photographs,” Office files, Office of Art & Archives, U.S. House of Representatives; House Telephone Directory, 90th Congress; House Telephone Directory, 98th Congress; House Telephone Directory, 99th Congress; House Telephone Directory, 101st Congress.