Elected in November 1966, Edward W. Brooke of
Massachusetts became the first Black lawmaker to
serve in the Senate in 86 years when he was sworn in
the following January. Brooke was the first popularly
elected Black Senator and the first Black lawmaker from
Massachusetts to serve in Congress. Brooke, a Republican,
was an independent thinker who often collaborated with
colleagues of both parties. Throughout his political career,
Brooke attempted to balance his support for legislation
designed to end racial inequality with a mistrust of what
he viewed as a “paternalistic government.” “Hand in hand
with the legal battles and demonstrations there must go
self-help,” Brooke said. “There must go with this quest for
equal opportunity an awareness of equal responsibility.”1
Edward William Brooke III was born in Washington,
DC, on October 26, 1919, to Helen, a homemaker,
and Edward Brooke Jr., a longtime lawyer with the U.S.
Veterans Administration. The future Senator was named
for his grandfather, father, and deceased sister Edwina.
He also had an older sister, Helene. After graduating from
Dunbar High School in Washington, DC, in 1936, Ed
Brooke attended Howard University. Originally intending
to pursue a career in medicine, Brooke decided to major in sociology, earning a bachelor’s degree in 1941. Shortly
after the Japanese bombed Pearl Harbor on December 7,
1941, Brooke entered the U.S. Army as a second lieutenant.
Before serving overseas in World War II, Brooke was
stationed with the segregated, all-Black 366th Infantry
Regiment at Fort Devens in Ayer, Massachusetts. Like many
Black Members of the era, Brooke felt keenly the irony and
indignity of fighting for democracy abroad while facing
racial discrimination in the armed forces. The Massachusetts
Army base implemented a Whites-only policy for all clubs,
as well as the swimming pool, the tennis courts, and the
general store. “In every regard, we were treated as secondclass
soldiers, if not worse, and we were angry,” Brooke
recalled. “I felt a personal frustration and bitterness I had
not known before in my life.” While stateside, Brooke
defended Black enlisted men in military court. Despite a
lack of legal training, he earned a reputation as a skilled
public defender and a “soldier’s lawyer.”2
Brooke spent 195 days with his unit in Italy. His fluent
Italian enabled him to cross enemy lines to communicate
with Italian partisans. By the war’s end, Brooke had earned
the rank of captain, a Bronze Star, and a Distinguished
Service Award. During his tour in Europe, he also met Italian-born Remigia Ferrari-Scacco. After a two-year,
long-distance relationship, they married on June 7, 1947,
in Roxbury, Massachusetts. The couple had two daughters:
Edwina and Remi. They divorced in 1978, and a year later
Brooke married Anne Fleming with whom he had a son,
Edward W. Brooke IV.3
Brooke’s legal experience on the Massachusetts military
base inspired him to earn a bachelor of laws degree in
1948 and a master of laws degree in 1950 from Boston
University. Brooke declined offers to join established law
firms, choosing instead to start his own practice in the
predominantly African-American Boston neighborhood,
Roxbury. At the urging of friends from his former Army
unit, Brooke interrupted his law career to run for the
Massachusetts house of representatives in 1950. Unsure of
his preferred party affiliation, Brooke took advantage of a
state law allowing candidates to cross-file. Though he had
no prior political experience, he received the endorsement
of the Republican Party for the house seat representing
Roxbury. Unsuccessful in the general election, Brooke
entered the race two years later, winning the Republican
nomination but losing to his Democratic opponent.4
Brooke established himself as a successful lawyer and
built community ties that proved significant in future
bids for elected office. In 1960, he ran for Massachusetts
secretary of state. Although Brooke lost that election, his
strong showing surprised observers. In recognition of his
performance in the campaign, Republican Governor John
Volpe of Massachusetts appointed Brooke chairman of the
Boston finance commission, which uncovered corruption
in the city’s municipal agencies. During his two-year tenure,
Brooke transformed the commission into a respectable and
effective organization. This position helped make him one
of the most popular political figures in the state.5
In 1962, Brooke earned the Republican nomination
for Massachusetts attorney general, then easily defeated
the Democratic challenger. Brooke garnered national
attention as the only member of his party to win statewide
election in 1962 and enjoyed the distinction of becoming
the state’s first African-American attorney general. Brooke
continued his efforts to thwart corruption in the state
government. He also recommended a series of measures
to protect consumers’ rights and fought to end housing
discrimination. Civil rights leaders criticized Brooke’s
decision that a proposed 1964 boycott by African-American
students to protest segregation in the Boston school system would be illegal. “I am not a civil rights leader and I don’t
profess to be one,” Brooke once declared, explaining the
conflict between his responsibility as an attorney general who
must uphold existing law and his personal views on racial
equality. His response to the proposed protest won him the
support of many voters in the predominantly White state.6
In 1966, Brooke authored The Challenge of Change: Crisis
in Our Two-Party System, outlining many of his political
principles, including his beliefs about civil rights. The “issue
[of civil rights] is pressing on the nation, and cries out
for a solution,” Brooke wrote, arguing that in addition to
legislation, African Americans needed access to educational
opportunities of high quality to compete with Whites.
While he promoted a civil rights agenda for reform, Brooke
maintained that militancy among activists undermined the
civil rights movement.7
After two terms as attorney general, Brooke announced
his candidacy in 1965 for the U.S. Senate seat left vacant
by the retirement of Leverett Saltonstall. Brooke was
unopposed in the Republican primary and faced Democrat
Endicott Peabody, the former governor of Massachusetts,
in the general election. Campaigning as a “creative
Republican,” Brooke successfully courted voters from both
parties. His criticism of the increasing militancy of some
civil rights activists resonated with many White voters in
Massachusetts. Although Peabody enjoyed the enthusiastic
backing of popular Massachusetts Senator Edward Moore
“Ted” Kennedy, he failed to break through with voters,
and on November 8, 1966, Brooke won a seat in the
90th Congress (1967–1969), taking 62 percent of the
vote. His victory met with considerable fanfare, both in
Massachusetts and across the nation. Brooke was the first
African-American candidate elected to the Senate since
the Reconstruction Era. Asked to comment on his victory,
Brooke praised the people of Massachusetts for their ability
to “judge you on your merit and your worth alone.” He
promised to use his position to “unite men who have not
been united before,” reiterating his pledge to represent his
constituents equally. In November 1972, Brooke easily
defeated Democrat John J. Droney, the Middlesex County
district attorney, earning 64 percent of the vote to win a
second term in the Senate.8
Initially assigned to the committees on Aeronautical and
Space Sciences, Banking and Currency, and Government
Operations, Brooke also served on the Armed Services
and the Joint Committee on Bicentennial Arrangements committees for one Congress. From the 92nd to the 95th
Congresses (1971–1979), Brooke was on three committees:
Appropriations; Special Aging; and Banking, Housing,
and Urban Affairs. Brooke also sat on the Select Equal
Educational Opportunity Committee, the Joint Committee
on Defense Production, and the Select Standards and
Conduct Committee.9
Despite being the first Black Senator since the nineteenth
century—and having been elected just two years after the
passage of the Civil Rights Act of 1964—Brooke claimed he
experienced little institutional racism in the Senate. “In all
my years in the Senate, I never encountered an overt act of
hostility,” he said. Brooke later recalled using the Senate gym
and the adjoining facilities without incident. Early in his
first term, Brooke went to the Senators’ swimming pool in
the Russell Senate Office Building. Southern Democrats and
staunch segregationists John Cornelius Stennis of Mississippi,
John Little McClellan of Arkansas, and James Strom
Thurmond of South Carolina greeted Brooke and invited
him to join them in the pool. “There was no hesitation or
ill will that I could see,” Brooke recollected. “Yet these were
men who consistently voted against legislation that would
have provided equal opportunity to others of my race. I felt
that if a senator truly believed in racial separatism I could live
with that, but it was increasingly evident that some members
of the Senate played on bigotry purely for political gain.”10
President Lyndon B. Johnson appointed Brooke to
the President’s Commission on Civil Disorders shortly
after he was elected to the Senate. Illinois Governor Otto
Kerner led the group, which became known as the Kerner
Commission. Charged with investigating the causes of the
urban riots of 1967, the Kerner Commission also proposed
solutions for the wide-spread incidences of looting and
violence in American cities. The 11-member commission
reported that American society was sharply divided along
racial lines. Brooke agreed with one of the commission’s
principal recommendations: that the government should
fund a series of programs to increase educational, housing,
and employment opportunities for people of color living
in urban areas. Although the commission’s reports received
widespread attention by scholars and in the press, President
Johnson disagreed with many of its findings, and the
commission’s recommendations were largely set aside
by policymakers.11
In the Senate, Edward Brooke was often at the forefront
of efforts to expand and protect the legislative achievements of the civil rights movement. Working with Democratic
Senator Walter F. Mondale of Minnesota, Brooke succeeded
in attaching an antidiscrimination amendment to the
groundbreaking Civil Rights Act of 1968. Title VIII of
the legislation included provisions to combat racial
discrimination in housing. “Fair housing does not promise
an end to the ghetto,” Brooke cautioned. “It promises
only to demonstrate that the ghetto is not an immutable
institution in America.” Brooke cited his own experience of
being one of the “lucky ones” that was fortunate enough to
“escape the ghetto,” and spoke of the “psychological impact”
of living in “an area which has been marked for second-class
citizens.” To combat the “unconscionable bitterness between
white and Black Americans, it is encumbent [sic] upon our
Government to act, and to act now,” Brooke said.12
In 1975, Brooke helped lead the effort in the Senate
to extend the 1965 Voting Rights Act. When a proposed
Senate amendment threatened to dilute the historic voting
rights legislation, Brooke joined the debate. “I just cannot
believe that here in 1975 on the floor of the Senate we are
ready to say to the American people, black or white, red or
brown, ‘You just cannot even be assured the basic right to
vote in this country.’” Brooke’s eloquent and impassioned
plea to his colleagues helped extend the landmark measure
for seven years. Shortly after the assassination of Martin
Luther King Jr. in 1968, Brooke urged his congressional
colleagues to recognize the renowned civil rights leader by
declaring January 15 (King’s birthday) a national holiday.
Arguing that it “would be fitting to pay our respects to
this noble figure by enduring public commemoration of
his life and philosophy,” the Massachusetts Senator earned
the support of many African Americans. Brooke also made
headlines when he traveled to Jackson State College in
Mississippi in May 1970 to help settle the situation after
police shot and killed two Black students. In 1977, he
successfully fought an amendment to a Health, Education
and Welfare (HEW) bill that would have prevented the
department from enforcing quotas to meet affirmative
action goals.13
As a Republican Senator from a state with a small Black
population, Brooke had different concerns, interests, and
constituencies than most other Black lawmakers, all of
whom served in the House of Representatives at the time.
Occasionally, this placed Brooke at odds with the Black
Representatives, and he never joined the Congressional
Black Caucus (CBC). But the Senator and House Members also found occasions to work with and support each other.
In 1969, both Brooke and the Black Members of the House
opposed Richard M. Nixon’s nomination of Clement F.
Haynsworth Jr. to the Supreme Court, and they coordinated
opposition. In 1971, Brooke declined to participate in the
Black Representatives’ boycott of President Nixon’s State
of the Union Address, but he did later support a meeting
between the Members and the President. Two years later,
Senator Brooke was the keynote speaker at the CBC’s
annual fundraiser dinner.14
Although Brooke maintained his Republican Party
affiliation, his stances were often contrary to the official
party line. During his two terms in the Senate, Brooke
backed affirmative action, federal set asides for contracts
with minority businesses, and public housing legislation.
He also favored extending minimum wage standards to
jobs not covered under the Fair Labor Standards Act,
providing tax incentives to companies to enable them to
hire more employees, and increasing operating subsidies for
commuter rail services and mass transit systems. Brooke was
a vocal opponent of antibusing legislation, and on several
occasions helped defeat or weaken strong antibusing bills
passed in the House. In 1974, he successfully defeated the
Holt amendment, introduced by Maryland Representative
Marjorie Sewell Holt, to a HEW appropriations bill that
would have effectively ended the federal government’s role
in school desegregation. At times Brooke broke party ranks
to work with Democrats in the Senate and the House. For
example, Brooke and then-House Majority Leader Thomas P.
“Tip” O’Neill Jr. of Massachusetts recommended a swift
increase in Social Security benefits in 1972.15
Although Brooke initially supported President Nixon,
he grew increasingly critical of the Nixon administration.
Saying that he was “deeply concerned about the lack
of commitment to equal opportunities for all people,”
Brooke denounced the White House for neglecting Black
communities and failing to enforce school integration.
In addition to Haynsworth, Brooke opposed two other
Nixon Supreme Court nominees: G. Harrold Carswell
and William H. Rehnquist. In May 1973, he introduced a
resolution authorizing the U.S. Attorney General to appoint
a special prosecutor to serve in all criminal investigations
arising from the Watergate scandal. Six months later, Brooke
became the first Republican Senator to publicly call for
President Nixon’s resignation. “There is no question that
the President has lost his effectiveness as the leader of this country, primarily because he has lost the confidence of
the people of the country,” Brooke remarked. “I think,
therefore, that in the interests of this nation that he loves
that he should step down, tender his resignation.” Brooke
also was one of the few Republicans to disagree publicly
with President Gerald R. Ford’s pardon of Nixon, deeming
it a “serious mistake.”16
Brooke also influenced American foreign policy, especially
during the Vietnam War. As he campaigned for the Senate
in 1966, Brooke called for increased negotiations with the
North Vietnamese rather than an escalation of the fighting.
In 1967, he went on a three-week fact-finding mission to
Southeast Asia, and then spoke about that experience in
his first formal speech in the Senate. Although Brooke had
hoped for a diplomatic solution to the conflict, he came
home from Vietnam convinced “that the enemy is not
disposed to participate in any meaningful negotiations” and
that President Johnson’s “patient” approach to Vietnam did,
in fact, have merit. Brooke was praised by those who found
his willingness to publicly change his position courageous
and criticized by many civil rights activists who believed
the Vietnam War siphoned valuable funding away from
vital domestic programs. Years later, Brooke maintained
that his maiden speech had been misinterpreted because
the press overlooked his continued support of a reduction
of American involvement in the region. As a moderate
Republican, Brooke grew impatient with the Nixon
administration’s aggressive policies in Southeast Asia, which
escalated the conflict with few signs of success. In 1970,
he and 15 members of his party voted for the Cooper–Church Amendment, which originated in response to
Nixon’s decision to invade Cambodia and prohibited the
use of American troops outside Vietnam. Brooke further
challenged the President’s war effort by voting for legislation
that established a time limit for the withdrawal of American
troops from Vietnam.17
Brooke’s solid support base in Massachusetts began to
wane after an acrimonious and public divorce in 1978 led
to allegations of financial misconduct. In the Republican
primary, Brooke faced a challenge from conservative
television talk show host Avi Nelson. Although he managed
to rebuff Nelson’s bid, the controversies surrounding
Brooke’s finances left him in a weakened position as he
entered the general election campaign. In November 1978,
Democrat Paul Efthemios Tsongas, a U.S. Representative
from Massachusetts, defeated Brooke, 55 to 45 percent.18
After leaving office, Brooke resumed the practice of
law in Washington, DC. In 1984, he became chairman of
a commercial bank in Boston, and one year later, he was
named to the board of directors of a large defense contractor.
Upon being diagnosed with breast cancer in 2002, Brooke
returned to the public spotlight to increase awareness of
breast cancer in men. In 2004, President George W. Bush
awarded Brooke the Presidential Medal of Freedom, the
nation’s highest civilian honor. In 2007, Brooke published
his autobiography, Bridging the Divide: My Life. A year later,
Congress awarded him the Congressional Gold Medal.
Brooke died at his home in Coral Gables, Florida, on
January 3, 2015.19
[ Top ]