HOLTZMAN, Elizabeth

HOLTZMAN, Elizabeth
Collection of the U.S. House of Representatives
1941–

Biography

A self–proclaimed political outsider, Elizabeth “Liz” Holtzman defeated a 50–year House veteran and powerful chairman to win a seat in the U.S. House of Representatives. During her four terms in the House, Holtzman earned national prominence as an active member of the Judiciary Committee during the Richard M. Nixon impeachment inquiry and as a cofounder of the Congressional Caucus on Women’s Issues.

Elizabeth Holtzman and her twin brother, Robert, were born on August 11, 1941, in Brooklyn, New York, to Russian immigrants Sidney Holtzman, a lawyer, and Filia Holtzman, a faculty member in the Hunter College Russian Department. Elizabeth Holtzman graduated magna cum laude from Radcliffe College in 1962 as a member of Phi Beta Kappa and received her J.D. from Harvard Law School in 1965, one of 15 women in her class of more than 500. After graduation, she returned to New York to practice law and became active in state Democratic politics. From 1967 to 1970, Holtzman managed parks and recreation as an assistant to New York City Mayor John Lindsay. From 1970 to 1972, she served as a New York state Democratic committee member and as a district leader from Flatbush. She also cofounded the Brooklyn Women’s Political Caucus.

In 1972, Holtzman mounted a long–shot campaign to unseat incumbent Congressman Emanuel Celler, who had represented central Brooklyn for half a century and was chairman of the powerful House Judiciary Committee.1 Though she lacked the funding that Celler mustered for the Democratic primary, Holtzman mounted an energetic grass–roots campaign by canvassing the urban district. “If I had known how little money we could raise, I would never have gotten into it,” Holtzman recalled. “But it was possible to use shoe leather and win a race.”2 She often introduced herself to patrons in lines outside movie theaters, emphasizing her commitment to constituent needs. “There was no hostility to the fact that I was a woman. I remember truck drivers leaning out of their trucks and saying, ‘I think it’s great … it’s fantastic that a woman is running,’” she recalled. “I found mothers taking their daughters up to me. They wanted their daughters to have a different conception of the possibilities for them.”3 Holtzman noted that the 84–year–old Celler had become increasingly distant from local affairs and had no Brooklyn district office. She further played on her substantive policy disagreements with the incumbent, who had for years bottled up the Equal Rights Amendment (ERA) in the Judiciary Committee and had been an unwavering supporter of the war in Vietnam, an unpopular stance in the Democratic district. Holtzman won the nomination by a narrow margin of 635 votes, whereupon Time magazine dubbed her “Liz the Lion Killer.”4 In the general election, Holtzman was the sound winner, with 66 percent to Republican Nicholas R. Macchio, Jr.’s 23 percent. Running as a Liberal Party candidate, Celler left the race in September, endorsing Holtzman; however, he still received 7 percent of the vote.5 “My victory says that no political figure, no matter how powerful, can forget about the people he was elected to serve,” Holtzman declared.6 In her subsequent three re–election bids, Holtzman never was seriously challenged, winning with margins of 70 percent or more.7

When Liz Holtzman took her seat in the 93rd Congress (1973–1975), at the age of 31, she became the youngest woman ever to serve in the House. Immediately after her election, Representative Holtzman obtained a seat on the powerful Judiciary Committee, where she served all four terms of her service. In the 94th Congress (1975–1977), she was assigned to the Budget Committee, where she remained through the 96th Congress (1979– 1981). Holtzman also served on the Select Committee on Aging in the 96th Congress.

From her seat on the Judiciary Committee, Holtzman gained notoriety through her participation in the Nixon impeachment hearings as a freshman Representative. Of her role in reaching a verdict, Holtzman said, “It’s the most serious decision I’ll ever have to make.”8 She later aggressively questioned President Gerald R. Ford about his pardon of Nixon and defended the government’s claim over the Nixon tapes and papers.9 In 1973, Holtzman filed suit to halt American military action in Cambodia, on the grounds that it had never been approved by Congress. A district court ruled the Cambodian invasion unconstitutional, but the court of appeals reversed the decision.

Like many of her Democratic colleagues, Holtzman challenged military spending levels and weapons programs in the post–Vietnam era. Holtzman praised the Jimmy Carter administration’s decision not to pursue a neutron bomb. “I think the people of the world have a right not to see life jeopardized by nuclear holocaust, and that means not only Russian life and American life but all life on this earth,” she said in a floor speech. “The development of the neutron bomb and the deployment of countless unnecessary nuclear weapons will simply take us further down the road to such a holocaust.”10

In 1977, Congresswomen Holtzman and Margaret Heckler of Massachusetts cofounded the Congressional Caucus for Women’s Issues. As co–chairs, they persuaded 13 other House women to join (three declined), and the group held its first meeting on April 19, 1977. Though the women Members had met informally since the early 1970s to discuss women’s issues, Holtzman had to allay the fears of many colleagues who were reluctant to join a formal caucus because they “felt their constituents wouldn’t understand working on women’s issues. Some were very worried that they would be embarrassed politically.”11 The organizers agreed that the caucus would be used as a forum to create momentum for legislation on which Members could find consensus rather than as a disciplined unit that spoke with one voice on all issues.12 One of the group’s first battles was for passage of the ERA. In 1978, Holtzman led the fight to secure a seven–year extension of the March 1979 ratification deadline, a move that many Members considered to be on shaky constitutional grounds when it was introduced in committee.13 Congress eventually added three–and–a–half years to the deadline. Holtzman also helped secure a prohibition on sex discrimination in federal programs during her time in the House. In a New York Times interview, Holtzman reflected on her role as a female legislator, “The vast majority of the legislation that’s been introduced affecting the status of women was introduced by women.”14

In 1980, rather than seek re–election for a fifth term in the House, Representative Holtzman entered the Democratic primary for nomination to the Senate. She won the heated contest for the nomination against Bess Myerson, a former Miss America–turned–consumer advocate, and Holtzman’s former boss, John Lindsay. The Congresswoman portrayed herself as a candidate who was not beholden to special interests and who stood up to the political machine: “I have never been handpicked by the bosses. I have never been handpicked by anyone.” It also marked the first time that a major party had nominated a woman to run for the Senate in New York. Holtzman ran on her record in the House stating that, “While others kept silent, I asked Gerald Ford the hard questions about whether the Nixon pardon was a deal,” and that she, “got Congress to pass the bill extending the time limit ratifying the Equal Rights Amendment.”15 In the general election, she ran in a three–way race that included the incumbent Republican Jacob Javits, who had lost the GOP primary but ran on the Liberal ticket, and the man who beat Javits, a little–known Long Island politician named Alfonse D’Amato. Despite her distinguished record in Congress, Holtzman narrowly lost to Republican candidate D’Amato, 44.8 percent to 43.5 percent, with Javits drawing off about 11 percent of the vote.16

A year after the loss of the Senate seat, Holtzman was elected district attorney of Brooklyn and served in that office until she was elected comptroller of New York City in 1989.17 In 1992, she entered the Democratic Senate primary against former House colleague Geraldine Ferraro and State Attorney General Robert Abrams for the nomination to challenge Senator D’Amato in the general election. In an internecine primary squabble, Holtzman accused Ferraro of ethics violations during her House career and of ties to the mafia.18 Abrams eventually won the Democratic nomination. Many observers believed that Holtzman’s campaign tactics had effectively ended her political career. In 1993, she failed in her bid for the Democratic nomination for city comptroller. Holtzman entered private law practice in New York City and published her memoirs in 1996.

Footnotes

1In 1972, reapportionment changed Celler’s district, extending the boundaries farther south. His constituency did not change dramatically. See Kenneth Martis, The Historical Atlas of Political Parties in the United States Congress: 1789–1989 (New York: MacMillan, 1989); Congressional Directory, 92nd Cong., 2nd sess. (Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office, 1972); Congressional Directory, 93rd Cong., 1st sess. (Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office, 1973).

2Howard Kurtz, “The Private Public Prosecutor: Elizabeth Holtzman, Tough and Guarded as Brooklyn’s DA,” 27 October 1987, Washington Post: D1.

3Susan Tolchin, Women in Congress (Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office, 1976): 95.

4“Liz the Lion Killer,” Time, 3 July 1972, Time; see also, Hope Chamberlin, A Minority of Members: Women in the U.S. Congress (New York: Praeger, 1973): 353.

5Lucia Johnson Leith, “In Congressional Races—‘At Least 10 May Be Winners,’” 3 November 1972, Christian Science Monitor: 14; “Election Statistics, 1920 to Present,” http://clerk.house.gov/member_info/electionInfo/index.aspx.

6Chamberlin, A Minority of Members: 353.

7“Election Statistics, 1920 to Present,” http://clerk.house.gov/member_info/electionInfo/index.aspx.

8“Tough Year for Freshman Class in Congress,” 20 June 1974, Christian Science Monitor: 5A.

9“Miss Holtzman Will Seek to Set Up Panel on Tapes,” 7 November 1974, New York Times: 26.

10Congressional Record, House 95th Cong., 2nd sess. (11 April 1978): 9668–9669.

11“The Women’s Caucus, 20 and Roaring,” 20 October 1997, Washington Post: C3.

12Irwin N. Gertzog, Congressional Women: Their Recruitment, Integration, and Behavior (Westport, CT: Praeger, 1995): 185–187; and generally chapters 9 through 11.

13Larry Steinberg, “The Long Haul for ERA—And Now, Division in the Ranks,” 31 December 1977, National Journal 9(no.52–53): 2006.

14“Women in Office: How Have They Affected Women’s Issues?” 4 November 1980, New York Times: B8.

15“Miss Holtzman Announces Bid for Javits’s Senate Seat” 9 January 1980, New York Times: B1.

16“Election Statistics, 1920 to Present,” http://clerk.house.gov/member_info/electionInfo/index.aspx.

17Selwyn Raab and Dennis Hevesi, “Holtzman’s 6 Years: Innovations and Antagonism,” 5 January 1998, New York Times: B1; Kurtz, “The Private Public Prosecutor: Elizabeth Holtzman, Tough and Guarded as Brooklyn’s DA.”

18Helen Dewar, “Political Sisterhood Sours in N.Y. Race: Bitter Rivalry of Ferraro, Holtzman Seen Benefiting Male Opponent,” 13 September 1992, Washington Post: A21.

View Record in the Biographical Directory of the U.S. Congress

[ Top ]

External Research Collections

New York City Department of Records and Information Services
Municipal Archives

New York, NY
Papers: In the Mayor's Economic Development Administration Files, 1967-1970, 2 cubic feet. The records document Elizabeth Holtman's role as assistant to Mayor John V. Lindsay.
Papers: In the Mayor's General Files, 1967-1969, 3 cubic feet. The records document Elizabeth Holtman's role as assistant to Mayor John V. Lindsay.

Radcliffe Institute for Advanced Study, Harvard University
Schlesinger Library

Cambridge, MA
Papers: 1970-1981, 295 feet. The papers of Elizabeth Holtman include correspondence, speeches, financial records, scheduling books, telephone logs, campaign literature, awards, clippings, photographs, records of case work, community work, and the Judiciary Committee, and administrative and legislative files cover primarily her election to and service in the U.S. House of Representatives and her unsuccessful campaign for election to the U.S. Senate. Subject files pertain to abortion, Cambodia, employment, environment, energy, housing and urban development, national security and the CIA, New York City, rape privacy, social security, public welfare, transportation, and the Congressional Women's Caucus. Included are questionnaire responses from constituents on Watergate, the energy crisis, wage and price controls, Nixon's pardon, Rockefeller's vice presidency, amnesty, and mail services; material on Nixon's impeachment hearings; and testimony from hearings on immigration and refugee policy. A finding aid is available in the repository. Much of the collection is restricted. The collection is stored off site and researchers must request access 36 hours before use.
Videotapes: 1987-1993, 12 videocassettes. The videocassettes contain mainly of media coverage of Elizabeth Holtzman. Included are news reports, talk show interviews, and press conferences, usually precipitated by a current event. There are also several speeches by Elizabeth Holtzman and a debate among U.S. Senate candidates. A finding aid is available in the repository. Restricted. Appointment required for viewing.
Oral History: 1973, 63 pages. The interview with Elizabeth Holtzman was conducted by Marilyn Shapiro and sponsored by the William E. Wiener Oral History Library of the American Jewish Committee.
Papers: In the Candidates for Public Office Campaign Materials, 1966-1976, 0.5 linear foot. Subjects include Elizabeth Holtzman.
Papers: In the Diana Mara Henry Photographs, 1969-1976, 49 folders and 1 oversize. Subjects include Elizabeth Holtzman.
Papers: In the Dorothy F. Rodgers Papers, 1922-1987, 4 linear feet. Subjects include Elizabeth Holtzman.
[ Top ]

Bibliography / Further Reading

"Elizabeth Holtzman" in Women in Congress, 1917-2006. Prepared under the direction of the Committee on House Administration by the Office of History & Preservation, U.S. House of Representatives. Washington: Government Printing Office, 2006.

Holtzman, Elizabeth J., with Cynthia L.Cooper. Cheating Justice: How Bush and Cheney Attacked the Rule of Law, Plotted to Avoid Prosection, and What We Can Do About It. Boston: Beacon Press, 2012.

___. The Impeachment of George W. Bush: A Practical Guide for Concerned Citizens. New York: Nation Books, 2006.

___. "Who Said It Would be Easy?" One Woman's Life in the Political Arena. New York: Arcade Publishers, 1996.

[ Top ]

Committee Assignments

  • House Committee - Budget
    • State and Local Governments - Chair
  • House Committee - Judiciary
    • Immigration, Refugees, and International Law - Chair
  • House Committee - Select Committee on Aging
[ Top ]